San Diego Vacation Rental Management Companies Compared
Objective comparison of Vacasa, Evolve, Casago, TurnKey, Awning, and local San Diego management. Everything you need to make an informed decision.
TL;DR: Which Company is Best for San Diego?
For maximum revenue and service: True local San Diego management (like Titan) consistently outperforms national companies due to intimate neighborhood knowledge, faster response times, and San Diego STRO licensing expertise.
Budget option: If you’re prioritizing absolute lowest cost over service quality, Evolve’s commission-only model may work – but expect minimal support and DIY management.
Complete San Diego Management Comparison
Compare all major vacation rental management companies operating in San Diego. Scroll horizontally to see all companies.
Detailed Company Breakdown
Vacasa
Who they are: Largest vacation rental management company in North America with 35,000+ properties. In San Diego, Vacasa operates through their acquisition of 710 Beach Rentals, which was a local company before being purchased by the national chain.
Pros:
- Local San Diego office (710 Beach Rentals)
- Wide platform distribution
- Professional photography included
- Established brand recognition
- Full-service management
Cons:
- Local office but corporate policies
- National call center support system
- Hidden fees beyond base rate
- Franchise model limits local control
Best for: Owners who want national brand recognition with a local San Diego office, though corporate policies and call center support remain. The 710 Beach Rentals acquisition brings local presence but national company structure.
Evolve
Who they are: “Tech-enabled” platform with 10% commission model and minimal hands-on management.
Pros:
- Lowest commission rate (10%)
- Good for hands-on owners
- No hidden fees
- Platform listing distribution
Cons:
- You handle cleaning/maintenance
- Minimal actual “management”
- You pay for photography separately
- No local San Diego support
Best for: DIY owners who want to manage their own property but need platform distribution. Not suitable for owners wanting full-service management.
Casago
Who they are: Multi-market company based in Arizona with tech-focused approach. Operates in San Diego through a local franchise, providing some local presence while maintaining corporate oversight and systems.
Pros:
- Local San Diego franchise office
- Better than largest chains
- Technology platform
- Full-service management
- Professional photography
Cons:
- Franchise model with corporate oversight
- Arizona headquarters makes final decisions
- App-first (less personal)
- Multi-market divided attention
Best for: Owners who want better service than Vacasa with some local presence, though franchise structure means corporate policies and multi-market focus remain.
TurnKey
Who they are: Mid-size national company operating in 40+ US markets with full-service model.
Pros:
- Full-service management
- Established presence
- Revenue guarantee program
- Owner portal
Cons:
- National company (not local)
- Generic multi-market approach
- Portal communication (impersonal)
- Limited San Diego expertise
Best for: Owners comfortable with national companies who value revenue guarantees over personalized service.
Awning
Who they are: Tech-forward company focused on AI-driven pricing with moderate service level.
Pros:
- Lower fees than Vacasa
- AI-powered pricing
- Modern dashboard
- Growing company
Cons:
- Relatively new/unproven
- Tech-first (less human touch)
- Add-on fees for services
- Not San Diego-focused
Best for: Tech-savvy owners willing to work with a newer company in exchange for lower fees and modern tools.
Titan Beach Rentals (Local San Diego Management)
Who we are: San Diego-based vacation rental management exclusively serving Mission Beach, La Jolla, Pacific Beach, and Ocean Beach.
What Makes Us Different:
- 100% San Diego focused
- Direct cell phone access
- Minute-level emergency response
- STRO licensing experts
- Neighborhood-specific strategy
- All-inclusive transparent pricing
Our Approach:
- We live in the neighborhoods we manage
- Face-to-face meetings available
- Local contractor relationships
- Attend to San Diego market daily
- Personal service + technology
- Your property, our full attention
What Most Owners Don’t Know: Hidden Fees
The “management fee” is often just the beginning. Here’s what companies may charge beyond their advertised rate:
Vacasa
- Software/platform fees
- Guest service fees
- Booking channel fees
- Linen program charges
- Various “administrative” fees
True cost: Often 35-40%+
Evolve
- 10% commission only
- But you pay for everything:
- Photography ($200-500)
- Cleaning (per booking)
- All maintenance
Transparent but DIY-heavy
Casago/TurnKey
- Base management fee
- Technology platform access
- Some booking fees
- Varies by market
Better than Vacasa, not fully transparent
Titan Beach Rentals
- One all-inclusive rate
- No hidden fees
- No software charges
- No platform fees
- Photography included
What you see is what you pay
How to Choose: Decision Framework
Ask yourself these questions to determine which management style fits your needs:
✓ Choose LOCAL San Diego Management if…
- You want maximum revenue optimization
- Personal service and direct communication matter
- You value minute-level emergency response
- San Diego STRO licensing expertise is important
- You want someone who knows your neighborhood intimately
~ Choose FULL-SERVICE NATIONAL if…
- You own properties in multiple markets
- Brand name recognition is your priority
- You don’t need local San Diego expertise
- Portal/app communication is sufficient
- You’re okay with slower response times
⚠ Choose EVOLVE (or self-manage) if…
- You live in San Diego and can manage actively
- You want to handle cleaning/maintenance yourself
- Lowest possible commission is your only priority
- You’re experienced with vacation rental operations
- You have time to respond to guest issues 24/7
Frequently Asked Questions
Which company is best for Mission Beach properties?
Mission Beach requires specialized knowledge of dual-water access, Tier 4 STRO licensing, and high-turnover management. True local San Diego companies have the advantage here. National companies often underperform in Mission Beach due to lack of neighborhood-specific expertise.
What’s the real cost difference between these companies?
Advertised rates are misleading. Vacasa advertises around 25% but true cost with fees is often 35-40%. Evolve is truly 10% but you handle everything. TurnKey/Casago land around 25-30% all-in. Local management is typically competitive with transparent all-inclusive pricing and better service.
Can I switch management companies mid-season?
Most contracts have 30-60 day termination clauses. Existing bookings stay with your current manager; new bookings transfer to the new company. With proper planning, transitions can happen with zero downtime even during peak season.
Do national companies understand San Diego STRO licensing?
National companies have general knowledge but lack San Diego-specific expertise. STRO licensing is tiered, complex, and constantly evolving. Local San Diego companies handle STRO applications, renewals, and compliance daily. This expertise often translates to fewer licensing issues and better regulatory compliance.
What should I ask during interviews with management companies?
Key questions: (1) Where is your team physically located? (2) Who will I talk to when there’s an emergency at 2 AM? (3) What’s your ALL-IN cost including every possible fee? (4) How many San Diego properties do you manage? (5) What’s your STRO licensing process? (6) Can I have direct contact info for my dedicated manager?
How much more can I make with local vs national management?
Results vary by property, but local management often outperforms by 20-40% due to better pricing strategies, faster response (fewer negative reviews), and neighborhood expertise. The difference is most pronounced in neighborhoods like Mission Beach and La Jolla where local knowledge significantly impacts bookings.
Ready to Compare What Your Property Could Earn?
We’ll show you exactly how your property would perform with each management approach – then let you decide what’s best for you.
Get Your Free Property Analysis →
📊 Revenue comparison across management styles
💰 True all-in cost breakdown
🏠 Neighborhood-specific recommendations
✅ No obligation, no pressure